Key takeaways
- The best under counter ice makers compared: five 15-inch built-ins checked for drain type, water line needs, daily output, storage and ice style.
- Top Pick: EdgeStar IB250SS Built-In Ice Maker
- Runner-up: Whynter UIM-155 Stainless Steel Built-In Ice Maker
- Also consider: EUHOMY 15-Inch Under Counter Ice Maker Machine
An under counter ice maker is the upgrade that ends the freezer-tray shuffle and the panic run to buy bagged ice. A built-in model lives in a cabinet bay, draws water from a plumbed line, and keeps ice ready around the clock. For home bars, busy kitchens, and anyone who entertains often, that convenience is hard to give up.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
It is important to be honest about what you are signing up for, though. These are appliances, not gadgets. Every model here needs a cold water line, a nearby outlet, and in most cases a drain or a drain pump for meltwater. EdgeStar flatly states in its manual that installation should be done by a licensed plumber, and that is the right expectation for the whole category. The five machines below all fit the standard 15-inch width class, but they differ sharply in ice type, output, and drainage.
This article contains affiliate links, and we may earn a commission when you buy through them at no extra cost to you.
Quick Answer
The EdgeStar IB250SS is the safest first choice for most kitchens: it fits the standard 15-inch cutout, makes up to 25 pounds of crescent ice a day, stores 20 pounds in a freezer-style bin, and needs no drain line. Every model here still needs a water line, an outlet and a plumber-grade install, so plan the plumbing before the purchase.
EdgeStar IB250SS Built-In Ice Maker
The IB250SS is the benchmark residential built-in, and its party trick is what it does not need: a drain. The storage bin is refrigerated like a small freezer, so finished ice stays frozen instead of melting into a puddle that has to go somewhere. That removes the biggest installation headache in this category: no gravity drain to route and no pump to maintain. You still need a water line and an outlet, and the manual still calls for a licensed plumber, but the job is simpler than for any draining model.
Output is a sensible middle ground: up to 25 pounds of crescent ice per day into a 20-pound removable bin. Crescent ice is hard and slow-melting, suiting everyday drinks and coolers well. The door is reversible, so it can hinge on either side of the cabinet run, and a water line and scoop are included.
Specs:
– Model: EdgeStar IB250SS
– Daily production: up to 25 lbs per maker
– Storage: 20 lbs, removable bin
– Ice type: crescent
– Drain: none required, refrigerated freezer-style bin
– Dimensions: 14.88 in W x 20.06 in D x 33.31 in H
– Electrical: 115V, 60Hz
– Door: reversible hinge
– Included: scoop, water line, bin
Whynter UIM-155 Stainless Steel Built-In Ice Maker
The UIM-155 is the compact option in this guide: at 25 inches tall it is far shorter than a standard counter height, which suits low openings and bar cabinetry where a full-height unit will not fit. Like the EdgeStar, it uses a freezer compartment that keeps stored ice frozen, so it also skips the drain line, and its front venting allows it to sit enclosed in a cabinet.
The trade-off is capacity. Whynter rates it at 12 pounds of crescent ice per day with a 6-pound bin, a top-up supply for a couple or small wet bar rather than a party machine. It draws 120 watts and ships with a water line, scoop, and bin. If your demand is modest and your opening is short, this is the least complicated built-in here; if you host crowds, look further down the list.
Specs:
– Model: Whynter UIM-155
– Daily production: 12 lbs per maker
– Storage: 6 lbs
– Ice type: crescent
– Drain: none required, freezer compartment
– Venting: front, built-in or freestanding
– Dimensions: 15 in W x 18 in D x 25 in H
– Power: 120 watts, 120 volts
– Included: scoop, bin, water line
EUHOMY 15-Inch Under Counter Ice Maker Machine
At the other end of the scale sits the EUHOMY, a commercial-style 15-inch machine rated by the maker at up to 90 pounds of clear cube ice per day. It produces 40 cubes per cycle, offers three selectable cube sizes, and stores 24 pounds in an insulated bin. That output is far beyond typical household demand, which is the point: this is the pick for serious home bars, big families, and light commercial duty.
The installation story is equally serious. The bin is insulated rather than refrigerated, so meltwater has to leave, and the EUHOMY uses gravity drainage through the included drain pipe. Your cutout therefore needs a drain route that runs downhill, or you will be adding a separate pump. The door is reversible, pipes and hardware are included, and self-cleaning plus a 24-hour timer reduce day-to-day fussing.
Specs:
– Model: EUHOMY CIM002-0618
– Daily production: up to 90 lbs per maker
– Storage: 24 lbs, insulated bin
– Ice type: clear cube, three sizes
– Drain: gravity, drain pipe included
– Dimensions: 14.96 in W x 20.39 in D x 33.58 in H
– Power: 203 watts, 115 volts
– Door: reversible hinge
– Features: self-cleaning, 24-hour timer, LCD control
KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS Built-In Nugget Ice Maker
Nugget ice has a devoted following, and the KoolMore is how you get it built in without stepping up to premium dealer brands. It makes up to 66 pounds a day of soft, chewable pearl nugget ice and stores about 17.5 pounds. KoolMore rates noise at 43 dB, which matters in open-plan kitchens. The unit is ETL listed, and the maker’s manual frames it for household use, so treat it as a residential machine, not a foodservice workhorse.
Its smartest feature is the built-in drain pump. Nugget bins are not refrigerated, so meltwater must drain, and the pump lets the machine push that water up to a sink drain instead of depending on a floor drain. That opens up island installs where gravity drainage is impossible. At 16.4 inches deep it is also the shallowest full-height unit here, though at roughly 61 pounds it is a two-person lift.
Specs:
– Model: KoolMore KM-BIM66-NSS
– Daily production: up to 66 lbs per maker
– Storage: 17.5 lbs
– Ice type: pearl nugget
– Drain: built-in drain pump
– Dimensions: 15 in W x 16.4 in D x 32.4 in H
– Noise: 43 dB maker rating
– Certification: ETL listed
– Included: ice maker, scoop
Whynter UIM-502SS Built-In Ice Maker
The second Whynter here is a different animal from the little UIM-155: a full-height clear-cube machine with a 25-pound bin and an included NSF-certified inline water filter, a thoughtful touch for owners on chlorinated city water. Whynter’s current materials headline production at up to 80 pounds per day, while the manual’s technical table lists a 50-pound daily capability under its stated test conditions, so plan around the conservative figure.
Two installation notes matter here. First, this model drains by gravity and includes a drain hose, so it needs the same downhill route as the EUHOMY. Second, at 23.6 inches deep it is by far the deepest machine here, and that depth can collide with plumbing or the back panel in a standard bay. Measure your cutout depth with door swing in mind before ordering.
Specs:
– Model: Whynter UIM-502SS
– Daily production: up to 80 lbs headline figure; manual rating 50 lbs per day
– Storage: 25 lbs
– Ice type: clear cube
– Drain: gravity, drain hose included
– Dimensions: 14.6 in W x 23.6 in D x 32.8 in H
– Water filter: NSF-certified inline filter included
– Electrical: 115V, 60Hz
– Warranty: one year limited per maker
How to Choose
Start with the cutout, not the catalog. The standard class here is 15 inches wide, but measure your opening’s width, height, and depth, then compare against the unit’s full dimensions, including door swing. Depth is the silent killer: these machines range from 16 to 24 inches deep, and a deep unit in a shallow bay never sits flush.
Next, decide your drain strategy before you fall in love with a model. Drainless freezer-bin designs like the EdgeStar and the small Whynter only need a water line. Gravity-drain models need a drain below the unit that the line can fall toward. A built-in pump, like the KoolMore’s, buys placement freedom when neither works. Match production to real demand: 12 to 25 pounds a day serves most households, while frequent entertainers should look at 50 pounds and up. Storage matters as much as output, because a big maker with a small bin still runs out at a party.
Finally, pick your ice. Crescent ice is hard and slow to melt, clear cubes suit spirits and presentation, and nugget ice is soft, chewable, and dilutes faster. Confirm the unit vents at the front if it will be fully enclosed, and plan an outlet within reach. If you want a cabinet-matching front, panel-ready versions exist in premium lines at higher cost; none of these five is panel-ready. Then book the plumber.
Who Should Skip
Skip the whole category if you rent, cannot tap a cold water line, or have no drain route and no interest in a pump model, because every machine here is a plumbed appliance. Skip it if your ice use is occasional: a countertop maker or freezer trays serve a few parties a year with far less hassle. Skip it if you are expecting a second freezer, since most bins are insulated rather than refrigerated. And skip it if the budget only covers the box itself, because a plumber and fittings are part of the real project.
FAQ
Do under counter ice makers need a drain?
Most do, but not all. Models with refrigerated freezer-style bins, like the EdgeStar IB250SS and Whynter UIM-155, keep ice frozen and need no drain. Models with insulated bins need either a gravity drain below the unit or a drain pump.
Can I install one myself?
It is within reach of an advanced DIYer who can tap a water line, add a shutoff valve, and route a drain to code. Manufacturers such as EdgeStar specify a licensed plumber, and a bad water connection can leak unnoticed for weeks, so professional installation is the safer default.
How much ice does a household actually need?
For daily drinks and a weekend cooler, 12 to 25 pounds of production per day is plenty for most homes. If you regularly host large groups or run a busy home bar, step up to the 50-to-90-pound class and weigh storage as well as output.
What is the difference between built-in and freestanding?
The same machine is often rated for both. Built-in use means the unit sits enclosed in a cabinet, which is only safe because these models vent heat at the front rather than the sides or back. Freestanding use means it stands on its own, with the same water, outlet, and drain requirements.
Final Verdict
For most kitchens, the EdgeStar IB250SS earns the top spot because it removes the drain from the equation while covering everyday demand in the standard footprint. Choose the Whynter UIM-155 for a short opening and light use, the EUHOMY when output is everything and you have a gravity drain, the KoolMore when nugget ice and a drain pump solve your layout, and the UIM-502SS when clear cubes and a bigger bin justify the deeper cabinet work.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveCollect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.
Create a wedding registryFree shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.






Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!