Key takeaways
- The best cocktail smokers compared plainly: cherry and oak chimney tops, battery smoking guns, torches, butane, wood chips and glass fit for home bars.
A smoked Old Fashioned is equal parts theatre and flavour, and the tool behind it comes in two shapes. Chimney smokers are small wooden tops that sit on the rim of the glass: you load a screen with wood chips, burn them with a butane torch, and let the smoke cascade into the drink. Smoking guns are handheld battery fans with a burn chamber and a hose, pushing cold smoke into any covered glass.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
This guide compares five drink smokers across both designs: two chimney tops from Middleton Mixology and Thousand Oaks Barrel, two Breville guns, and a Homia gun kit with lids for trapping smoke. What separates them is what sits in the box: torch, butane, chip flavours, glass fit and cleaning.
This article contains affiliate links, and we may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.
Quick Answer
For most home bars, the Middleton Mixology SmokeTop kit is the easiest buy: the cherry chimney arrives with a torch, a can of butane, four wood flavours and five spare screens, so the first smoked Old Fashioned needs nothing extra. Choose a Breville gun instead if you also want to smoke food under a cover.
Middleton Mixology SmokeTop Cocktail Smoker Kit with Torch and Butane
The SmokeTop is a chimney-style smoker turned from American cherry wood. It rests on the rim of the glass, so the wood never touches the drink. Fill the mesh screen with chips, hold the torch above the chimney, and the smoke falls into the glass. Middleton Mixology rates the job at five to ten seconds per cocktail.
This kit, model St-001, is the complete version: the top, an angled torch, a 90 ml can of butane, four tins of chips — cherry, hickory, maple and oak — and five spare screens. Middleton rates each top for about 500 uses and backs it with a lifetime guarantee on its product page.
Specs:
– Type: Chimney smoke top that sits on the glass rim
– Material: American cherry wood, food-safe mineral oil finish
– Torch: Angled butane torch included
– Butane: 90 ml can included
– Wood chips: 4 tins — cherry, hickory, maple and oak
– Spare parts: 5 spare screens included
– Glass fit: Rocks glasses; maker says a coupe works for a Manhattan
– Care: Hand wash; rinse in warm water and dry well
– Origin: Made in the USA
See it on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09CW433DR?tag=besticeshaver06c-20
Breville Smoking Gun Pro CSM700
The Smoking Gun Pro is the commercial member of the Breville gun family, sold under the Breville Commercial and PolyScience names. Chips smoulder in a one-inch burn chamber, a fan draws the smoke through a removable barrel, and a silicone hose delivers it under a cloche or into a shaker. Because the smoke is cold, it never warms the drink.
Its control is the reason to pick it over simpler guns: a dial varies the fan speed continuously, from gentle to intense, instead of fixed settings. The box holds the gun, four mesh screens, tools, a booklet, batteries and two half-ounce wood samples, applewood and hickory. No lid or cloche is included. Chips are lit with a match or lighter, so no torch or butane is involved.
Specs:
– Type: Handheld smoking gun with silicone hose
– Power: 4 AA batteries, included
– Fan control: Variable speed dial
– Burn chamber: 1 inch diameter, removable without tools
– Cleaning: Burn chamber and barrel removable; dishwasher safe per maker
– Wood chips: 2 samples — applewood and hickory
– Filters: 4 mesh screens, plus hex key and set screw
– Dimensions: 6.75 x 3.25 x 5.75 inches
– Weight: 1 lb
– Warranty: 1 year
See it on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01MSB5USZ?tag=besticeshaver06c-20
Foghat Cocktail Smoker with Bourbon Barrel Wood Shavings
The Foghat turns the chimney idea into a piece of bar furniture, hand-turned on a lathe from a solid piece of white oak at the Thousand Oaks Barrel Co. workshop in Manassas, Virginia. A stainless steel mesh chamber sits in the top; add a pinch of shavings, light them with a torch, and the smoke pours into the glass in a cascading waterfall.
This listing is the top plus fuel only: no torch, no butane, so it makes sense only if a culinary torch already lives in your kitchen drawer. You get a tin of the maker’s bourbon barrel oak shavings — wood from aged bourbon barrels, which the maker describes as giving notes of caramel, vanilla, nuts, autumn spice and honey. The maker says it fits most standard rocks and Old Fashioned glasses, and names snifters too, with a burn of five to fifteen seconds per drink.
Specs:
– Type: Chimney smoke top that sits on the glass
– Material: Hand-turned solid white oak, stainless steel mesh chamber
– Torch: Not included — a small culinary torch is required
– Butane: Not included
– Wood chips: Bourbon barrel oak shavings, one flavour
– Glass fit: Most standard rocks and Old Fashioned glasses; maker also names snifters
– Spare parts: Replacement mesh guards sold in 3-packs
– Care: Never submerge in water; tap out ash, brush chamber, wipe dry
– Origin: Hand-turned in Manassas, Virginia, USA
See it on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HX68MLQ?tag=besticeshaver06c-20
Homia Fuma Universal Cocktail Smoker Kit
The Homia Fuma Universal Kit is a smoking gun sold as a complete trapping system rather than a bare tool. Alongside the battery gun and its flexible hose, the box includes three covers: a flat disk lid, a wide smoking lid, and a tall glass cocktail lid with an LED light for presentation. The hose feeds smoke under whichever lid you choose, so one kit handles glasses and bowls of different sizes.
Fuel variety is the other headline. Seven flavours of wood chips come in the box, the widest count here, along with four AA batteries, a cleaning brush and a mesh set. No torch or butane is needed; chips are lit in the chamber and the fan does the rest. The trade-off is assembly: lids and hose must be fitted before each use. Fan speed settings are not stated on the listing, so expect simpler smoke control than the Breville dial models.
Specs:
– Type: Handheld smoking gun with hose and lid set
– Kit size: 14 pieces
– Covers included: Disk lid, wide smoking lid, tall glass cocktail lid with LED light
– Power: 4 AA batteries, included
– Wood chips: 7 flavours included; flavour names not stated on the listing
– Cleaning: Cleaning brush and extra mesh set included
– Glass fit: Set by the included lids rather than a fixed rim size
See it on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08B3GTCXT?tag=besticeshaver06c-20
Breville the Smoking Gun BSM600SIL
The original Breville Smoking Gun is the home version of the Pro above: a battery fan, a removable die-cast stainless steel burn chamber and a silicone hose. It makes the same cold smoke, so it works on cocktails and just as happily on butter, cheese or anything else you can cover.
Control is a switch rather than a dial. Breville calls the two fan speeds Gentle and Intense, and its manual’s method is to start on high so the chips catch, then drop to low once smoke flows from the hose. The box covers the first drinks with filters, batteries, an instruction book with recipe cards, and two chip samples, hickory and applewood. There is no lid in the box — Breville sells a cloche separately — and the samples will not last regular smokers long.
Specs:
– Type: Handheld smoking gun with silicone hose
– Power: 4 AA batteries, included
– Fan control: 2 speeds — Gentle and Intense
– Burn chamber: Removable die-cast stainless steel
– Cleaning: Burn chamber and barrel removable; dishwasher safe per maker
– Wood chips: 2 samples — hickory and applewood
– Filters: 2 mesh filters plus replacement filters included
– Dimensions: 4.5 x 2.5 x 6.5 inches
– Warranty: 1-year limited
See it on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B072RCDQJS?tag=besticeshaver06c-20
How to Choose
Start with the design. A chimney top is a one-glass ritual: fast, quiet and dramatic, but it only smokes what fits under its rim. A gun is slower to set up yet far more flexible — the hose fills a cloche, shaker, decanter or sealed container, and it smokes food as readily as drinks. If smoked cocktails are the whole hobby, a top is enough; if the smoke might wander into the kitchen, buy a gun.
Then check ignition. Chimney tops need a butane torch: the SmokeTop kit includes torch and butane, the Foghat neither. Guns skip butane — chips are lit with a match or lighter — but trade that for batteries and chamber cleaning. Finally, count consumables: chip flavours run from one to seven, screens wear out on every design, and cleaning ranges from dishwasher-safe metal to oak that must never touch water.
Who Should Skip
Skip the Foghat if you do not already own a culinary torch, because that listing cannot smoke a first drink on its own. Skip chimney tops altogether if your glasses are mostly wide coupes, pints or stemware the top cannot sit on, or if you often smoke several drinks at once — a gun under one large cover handles that better. Skip the guns if you dislike small-appliance upkeep: batteries, mesh filters and ash emptying are part of the routine. Skip all of them if open flame or lingering smoke is a problem in your space.
FAQ
Do I need a torch for every cocktail smoker?
No. Only the chimney tops need one, because their chips burn in an open screen. The SmokeTop kit includes a torch and butane; the Foghat needs a torch you supply yourself. Smoking guns light their chips with a match or lighter and use a battery fan, so butane never enters the picture.
How long should the smoke stay on the drink?
Less than most beginners expect. Middleton Mixology rates five to ten seconds of smoke per cocktail for the SmokeTop, and Foghat says five to fifteen seconds. A short rest after the burn gives clear flavour; long burns push the drink toward ash and bitterness.
Which wood chips suit whiskey best?
Oak is the traditional start, and barrel-aged oak — like the Foghat’s bourbon barrel shavings — is the flavour most makers build their whiskey kits around. Cherry reads sweeter and lighter, hickory stronger and more savoury, maple in between. Multi-flavour kits such as the SmokeTop and Homia sets let you taste the difference on the same bourbon.
Can one smoker handle drinks for a whole group?
A chimney top smokes one glass at a time, though each drink takes only seconds, so a round of Old Fashioneds is still quick work. For batch presentation, a gun feeding smoke under one large cloche or lid — the Homia kit’s wide lid, for example — can cover several glasses at once.
Final Verdict
For a first cocktail smoker, the Middleton Mixology SmokeTop kit is the most complete box here: torch, butane, four woods and spare screens in one purchase. The Foghat suits torch owners who want a hand-turned oak original and one well-chosen barrel flavour. If the smoke should reach beyond the glass — cheese, butter, a whole cloche of drinks — the Breville Smoking Gun Pro offers the finest control, the standard Smoking Gun covers the same ground, and the Homia Universal Kit bundles the lids that make trapping smoke easy.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveCollect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.
Create a wedding registryFree shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.






Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!