Key takeaways
- Compare the best ice cube trays with lids for spill-free carrying, stacking and odor-free storage, from sealed silicone trays to bin-and-scoop sets.
- Top Pick: OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
- Runner-up: DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack
- Also consider: ICEBREAKER POP 2.0
An open ice tray is a small spill waiting to happen. It sloshes on the walk from sink to freezer, it cannot be stacked under a bag of peas, and the cubes slowly absorb odours from whatever else shares the shelf. A lidded tray fixes all three problems at once: the cover keeps water in while you carry the tray, it blocks freezer smells while the ice sits in storage, and it gives you a flat surface so trays and food can stack on top.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
The five trays below cover the main designs worth buying: a sealed silicone-lid tray, two tray-and-bin systems that keep a reserve of loose cubes ready to serve, a sealed dispenser you never touch the ice in, and a stackable silicone set for small freezers. Each is judged on lid seal, release method, cube count and footprint, including fit in narrow drawers and side-by-side freezer columns.
This article contains affiliate links, and we may earn a commission when you buy through them at no extra cost to you.
Quick Answer
The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray is the best all-round choice: its silicone lid seals each of the 14 cubes, so a filled tray can be carried at an angle and stacked without spills or freezer odours. For bigger batches, the DOQAUS four-tray set with storage bin and scoop keeps 56 cubes ready to serve.
OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
The No-Spill tray is built around its silicone lid. After filling, you lay the lid over the tray and smooth it down, and it seals each cube compartment individually. That seal is what makes the design work: excess water can be poured off after sealing, the filled tray can be carried tilted without leaking, and it can sit on an uneven pile of frozen food while it sets.
Release is the other strong point: the rounded cube shape and a twist of the tray let cubes drop out without banging on the counter, and the lid comes off completely for washing. The trade-off is capacity — at 14 cubes per fill this is a modest tray with a footprint larger than the cube count suggests, so measure a narrow drawer before ordering a pair.
Specs:
– Cubes per tray: 14
– Lid type: Silicone lid that seals each cube compartment
– Material: Silicone lid; tray material not stated
– Cube size: not stated
– Care: Lid removable; tray is top-rack dishwasher safe
– Model reference: UPC 719812033204
DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 4 Pack
DOQAUS sells this as a small ice system rather than a single tray. Four silicone trays with spill-resistant lids freeze the cubes, and a lidded storage bin with a scoop holds the finished ice so the trays can go straight back to work. Across the four trays you get 56 cubes per batch, which suits households that empty a tray into drinks every day and want a reserve instead of a single layer of ice.
The silicone trays release cubes with a push from underneath, so there is no twisting against a rigid frame. The trays stack on each other or on the bin, and the whole set is compact enough for an RV freezer or a small apartment freezer. The listed set size is 8.2 by 4.5 by 3.6 inches, which helps when planning drawer space. Because the trays flex, carry them with two hands when full; a bowing tray can work a lid loose if grabbed by one corner.
Specs:
– Pack contents: 4 silicone trays, 4 spill-resistant lids, 1 storage bin with lid, 1 ice scoop
– Cubes per batch: 56 total across the four trays
– Listed set size: 8.2 x 4.5 x 3.6 inches
– Model number: IC9
– Material: Silicone trays; bin material not stated
– Dishwasher safe: not stated
ICEBREAKER POP 2.0
The ICEBREAKER POP takes a different approach: it is a sealed ice maker and server in one unit. You fill it through the top, lay it flat in the freezer, and when the water is frozen you pull the straps on both sides to crack the cubes loose inside the sealed body. The cubes are then poured or shaken out through the opening, so your hands never touch the ice and the ice never sits exposed in the freezer.
That sealed design is the appeal for shared freezers, offices and anyone who dislikes open ice sitting next to raw food. It makes 18 cubes per fill, and the flat body stacks with food or a second unit on top. The unit also comes apart for cleaning, which matters because a closed body needs a proper wash rather than a rinse. It freezes a single batch at a time, so heavy ice users will want loose-cube storage alongside it.
Specs:
– Cubes per fill: 18
– Release method: Pull-strap cracking inside a sealed body; cubes are dispensed without hand contact
– Material: Silicone
– Model number: BSK2290
– Disassembly for cleaning: Yes, the unit comes apart
– Dishwasher safe: not stated
WIBIMEN Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin, 1-Inch Round, 2 Pack
Round cubes are the draw here. Each of the two trays forms 33 small spheres, so a full batch gives you 66 one-inch ice balls, and the set includes a storage bin and tongs for serving. Small round cubes chill quickly and pack tightly into a glass, which makes them a good fit for iced coffee, juice and cocktails where you want fast cooling rather than one slow-melting cube.
The trays are rigid BPA-free plastic rather than silicone, and release works by twisting the tray so the spheres pop free into the bin. A lid seals each tray for carrying and stacking, and the lid on the bin keeps the stored ice covered. Rigid trays need a firm twist when the cubes are fully frozen, so this set suits adults more than small hands. The compact trays also sit well in the narrow freezer column of a side-by-side fridge, where long trays often do not fit across the shelf.
Specs:
– Pack contents: 2 round ice trays, 1 storage bin, 1 pair of tongs
– Cubes per batch: 66 round cubes (33 per tray)
– Cube size: 1 inch round
– Material: BPA-free plastic
– Release method: Twist release
– Dishwasher safe: not stated
PET Hous Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid, Set of 4
This set is the straightforward stackable option: four flexible silicone trays, each with its own fitted lid, each forming 15 cubes of about 1.2 inches. Stacked together they store 60 cubes in roughly the footprint of one standard tray, which is exactly what a crowded freezer drawer needs. The lids keep each layer sealed against odours and stop the tray above from pressing into the water below.
Release is the classic silicone push: press up under a cube and it pops out, or give the tray a gentle twist to free a full row. The soft moulds also suit freezing coffee, stock, sauces and baby food in small portions, with the lids keeping those stores tidy. Carry a filled tray on a flat hand or a small board, since a flexible tray full of water bows in the middle if held by the edges.
Specs:
– Pack contents: 4 silicone trays with individual lids
– Cubes per batch: 60 total (15 per tray)
– Cube size: 1.2 x 1.2 x 1.2 inches
– Material: Food-grade silicone, BPA free
– Release method: Push from underneath or twist
– Dishwasher safe: not stated
How to Choose
Start with the lid, because it decides how you can carry and store the tray. A sealing silicone lid, like the OXO design, lets you move a filled tray at an angle and stack food on top. A rigid snap-on or spill-resistant lid is fine for stacking and odour protection, but carry the tray flat. If the ice will sit in storage for days, a lid on the storage bin matters as much as the lid on the tray.
Next, match the release method to your hands. Silicone trays release by pushing or flexing, which is easy on wrists and frees one cube at a time. Rigid plastic trays release by twisting; they are durable and stack neatly, but a fully frozen tray takes some force. Sealed dispensers avoid the question entirely, cracking the cubes loose inside the unit.
Then count cubes honestly. A household that ices two drinks a day is fine with a single 14-cube tray. Daily iced coffee, family dinners or regular cocktails call for a tray-and-bin system or a multi-tray set, so one batch is always frozen while another is served. Finally, measure your freezer: check drawer and side-by-side column widths, and leave a little headroom above a lidded tray for the lid and stacking.
Who Should Skip
Skip lidded trays if your fridge has a working built-in ice maker — a tray will only duplicate it and eat freezer space. Skip the small sealed dispensers if you regularly need ice for a party cooler; a single 18-cube batch cannot keep up, and a bin system or bagged ice makes more sense. Skip flexible silicone trays if you know you will carry them one-handed across the kitchen, because a bowing tray can shift its lid. And skip round-cube trays if you want slow-melting ice for whisky, since small spheres melt faster than one large cube.
FAQ
Do lids really stop ice from absorbing freezer odours?
A lid that seals or closely covers the tray greatly reduces odour transfer, because the cubes are no longer exposed to the air circulating past strong-smelling food. A sealing silicone lid gives the strongest protection; a loose snap-on lid helps, but ice stored for weeks can still pick up some taste, so rotate stored ice rather than keeping it indefinitely.
Are silicone trays easier to release than plastic trays?
For most people, yes. Silicone flexes, so you can push a single cube out from underneath without twisting the whole tray. Rigid plastic trays need a twist, which frees the whole batch at once but takes more force. If you only ever need a few cubes at a time, silicone is the more convenient choice.
How many trays fit in a narrow freezer drawer?
Measure the drawer width against the tray footprint before buying. Compact sets around 8 inches long, and trays that stack vertically with lids, use drawer space best. Side-by-side columns are often too narrow for long trays laid across, so shorter trays or a bin system fit better.
Can I put these trays in the dishwasher?
It depends on the model. The OXO tray in this guide is top-rack dishwasher safe; for the other sets here the makers do not state dishwasher guidance, so wash them by hand in warm soapy water unless the packaging says otherwise. Silicone can pick up detergent taste from heavily scented products.
Final Verdict
For most kitchens, the OXO Good Grips No-Spill tray is the one to buy: the sealing silicone lid solves carrying, stacking and odour problems at once, and the cubes release cleanly. If your household burns through ice daily, step up to the DOQAUS tray-and-bin set for its 56-cube batches and scoop. The ICEBREAKER POP is the hygienic pick for shared freezers, the WIBIMEN set is the fast-chilling round-cube option, and the PET Hous four-pack is the stackable set for small freezers.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveCollect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.
Create a wedding registryFree shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!